Working with researchers from the University of Bedfordshire, SOS Children’s Village have produced an extensive report exposing the prevalence of violence towards children in alternative care settings in 21 different countries around the world. The report offers practical recommendations to governments, care providers and other stakeholders for the protection of children from violence in these situations. Child protection is promoted as a shared responsibility and, accordingly, the report encourages enhanced communication networks, greater transparency and more effective whistle blowing systems. A key premise is that knowledge exchange is vital for ending violence against children. As such, this report does not rest content with detailing cases of violence but also asks probing questions about why and how it manifests in the context of alternative care.

The significant lack of data pertaining to children in care is a recurrent theme throughout this document. Accessing reliable information requires: (a) that the ‘taboo’ nature of discussions about violence against children is challenged and (b) negotiating the ethical complexities involved in child participation/ consultation in such research. A series of UN reports as well as the UN’s 2009 Guidelines for the Alternative Care of Children establish that violence against children cuts across the boundaries of culture, class, education, income and ethnicity. Professionals thus need to challenge assumptions about which forms of violence are most harmful to children’s well-being and which groups are most at risk. Evidence suggests that misguided beliefs about vulnerability can sometimes lead to the under-estimation of just how vulnerable less ‘obvious’ groups are to abuse and violence: e.g. boys and older children.

The concept of ‘violence’ is most commonly associated with physical or sexual assault. However, analysis shows that equally fervent measures should be taken against psychological/ emotional forms of violence since these can just as often result in negative long-term consequences. Although researchers are clear about the dangers inherent in assuming that certain forms of care place children at greater risk than others, there is a correlation between institutionalised/ group care systems and the likelihood of experiencing emotional harm. This correlation is particularly pronounced in children under 3 years old. Opportunities to form deep personal bonds are limited in institutional environments, the repercussions of which can be profound in terms of brain development and cognitive, social and behavioural capacity.

The detrimental long-term consequences of psychological abuse are the more concerning given the pervasiveness of this type of violence within alternative care. For example, a survey undertaken in Armenia revealed that 44% of children living in residential care had been subject to both physical and psychological violence. An especially worrying finding of this report is that, in almost all of the 21 countries assessed, those responsible for the delivery of care were: “underpaid and overworked and many times under-qualified or not qualified at all” (p.56). Without professional child-care training, the personal values, cognitive biases and discriminatory beliefs and practices of those charged with protecting and promoting children’s rights may go unchecked. Gender, disability, HIV status and ethnicity have all been found to influence a child’s vulnerability to violence, including psychological violence. In the context of alternative care settings, therefore, emotional abuse can often take the form of shunning or exclusion from the group by peers and inadequately qualified staff alike. It is also noted that belonging to a socially discriminated against group can increase a child’s chances of entering alternative care in the first place; as in the case of over-representation of Roma children in institutionalised care systems.

Despite the many atrocities documented in this report, overwhelmingly, there is a message of hope. Alternative care systems are not inextricably linked to violence and nor is violence inevitable. Moreover, by aligning practices with the UN’s 2009 Guidelines, alternative care might yet fulfil its intended purpose: the protection of children at their most vulnerable. 

To read the full report click here

Childhub

You might like..

0
16
The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) recognises children as the subjects of rights, as well as their vulnerability and need for “special safeguards and care”.1 The UNCRC is notably one of the most ratifed UN conventions in history…
yes
0
561
In this European Parliamentary report, which exposes the prevalence and multifaceted nature of violence towards children across Europe, the common assumption that violence is more of a problem for developing nations is squashed. In fact, the…
yes
0
303
As part of the Ending Violence Against Children in Custody project, the Children’s Rights Alliance for England (CRAE) partnered with five human rights/ juvenile justice organizations across Europe in order to report children’s experience of violence…
yes
0
3628
Despite the fact that all 28 members of the European Union have ratified the UNCRC, violence continues to blight the lives of millions of children across Europe. In this report the FRA (European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights) identifies…
yes
0
1701
UNICEF has examined the outcomes of numerous violence prevention and intervention programmes implemented around the globe and has consequently identified six strategies shown to be highly effective. The intervention and response projects outlined in…
yes
0
5186
In their extensive 2012 report, UNICEF, working in partnership with the Council of Europe and the Norwegian government, highlighted the importance of eradicating all forms of violence from educational systems. Violence in schools can manifest in an…
yes
0
419
Collaborating with the European Council and the Norwegian government, in 2012, UNICEF compiled a report detailing the prevalence of violence in schools from a global perspective. The report offers several practical recommendations to governments,…
yes
0
8109
The Roma community faces a multitude of discriminatory practices. In this 2014 report, “On Discrimination of Roma Children in Education”, the European Commission argues for holistic strategies to achieve the end of Roma discrimination in educational…
yes
0
32643
This ChildHub review highlights that the more we know about the consequences of violence towards children the clearer the moral imperative to address it becomes. In both the short and the long term, exposure to violence during childhood has…
yes
0
243
In 2011 UNICEF and the EU entered a new partnership for the purposes of running the Protecting Children from Violence in South East Europe project. Initially four countries fell under the project’s remit: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Serbia and…
yes
0
1854
In a 2011 study, the National Foundation for Educational Research (NEFR) in the UK explored the different manifestations of bullying in almost 100 secondary schools and, through pupil participation, was able to reveal interesting findings about…
yes
0
64
Child participation in all aspects of modern society is extremely important for the good development of children. Furthermore it is important that children belonging to vulnerable groups that are already marginalized in society have an increased…
0
2082
This infographic provides some quick information on burnout, including it's factors and how to deal with it as an organisation or individually.
0
72
This infographic provides some quick information on burnout, including by highlighting the differences between it and stress as well as some of its consequences. It also provides the percentage of burnout among aid workers and the main fields that…
0
7
This video features a brief interview with Terre des hommes regional coordinator Vera Dimitrievska, in which she talks about the ways of detecting and addressing the issue of burnout among social workers working with the refugees.…