Abstract. “In this contribution a number of procedural issues related to the sentencing of child offenders and emanating from the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 are considered in some detail. As a general rule, the Act requires pre-sentence reports to be obtained from probation officers before sentencing any child offender, with only a limited number of exceptions. The article argues that the peremptory nature of the Act means that a probation report is always required, even if reports by other experts are also available. The exceptions are limited to instances other than those where the child offender is sentenced to any form of imprisonment or to residence in a care centre. The article addresses the question of whether or not the reference to imprisonment includes alternative imprisonment which is imposed only as an alternative to a fine. It suggests that alternative imprisonment should, generally, not be imposed on child offenders. When an exception is not prevented because of the sentence, a pre-sentence report may be dispensed with only when the offence is a schedule-1 offence (the least serious class of offences) or when obtaining a report would prejudice the child. It is argued that these exceptions are likely to occur rather rarely. A final aspect of the Act’s provisions on pre-sentence reports is the requirement that reasons be given for a departure from the recommendations in a pre-sentence report. This requirement merely confirms the status quo. The Act permits the prosecutor to provide the court with a victim impact statement. Such a statement is defined in the Act. It is a sworn statement by a victim or someone authorised by the victim explaining the consequences to the victim of the commission of the crime. The article also addresses the issue of whether or not the child justice court might mero motu obtain a victim impact statement when the prosecution does not do so. Finally, the article addresses appeals against and reviews of the trial courts’ sentences. It notes that appeal by the child offender is made somewhat easier, as some child offenders need not obtain leave to appeal. These include children under the age of 16, or older children sentenced to imprisonment. Again, the meaning of “imprisonment” is at least somewhat ambiguous. The provisions on automatic review have attracted considerable judicial attention already. The majority of these judgments confirmed the apparently clear wording of the Act, in terms of which the cases of all child offenders under the age of 16 should be reviewed regardless of whether they were legally represented or of the sentence imposed. In the case of child offenders aged 16 or 17, only custodial sentences are reviewable. The judgments which found this to be an incorrect interpretation are dealt with in some detail, with the conclusion that they were incorrectly decided” (Terblanche, 2013).


To access the full document, please visit this link.

Reference

Terblanche, S.S. (2013). The Child Justice Act: Procedural Sentencing Issues, Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 16(1), pp. 321-350. doi: 10.4314/pelj.v16i1.10

Publication type
Author
Terblanche S.S.
Language of materials
Projects and thematic pages

Childhub

You might like..

0
834
Abstract. “The Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 establishes a criminal justice system for child accused, separate from the criminal justice system which continues to apply for adult accused in South Africa. The Act aims to keep children out of detention…
0
43
This study explores the representation and human rights situation of Romani children in institutional care in Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Italy, Romania and Slovakia. It follows a report issued by the European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC)…
yes
0
48
Description of the webinar: For children in migration, access to their rights relies on multiple administrative and administrative justice proceedings. However, these various migration-related procedures are, in most cases, unsuitable for children,…
0
25
This facilitators training guide has been developed by Keeping Children Safe to support those delivering training on child safeguarding. This guide focuses on exercises and tools that can be used to ensure organisations child safeguarding measures…
0
9
Eurochild member COPE's child participation projects gather experiences of children of incarcerated parents An estimated 2.1 million children are separated from a parent in prison in Europe countries on any given day…
0
20
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) has published a report highlighting the magnitude of child poverty in the EU, but also presented some of the tools available to counter this phenomenon and keep track of progress made. In the link below you…
no
0
30
A call has been issued by Global Solutions Forum on Child Labor 2021 for effective action and strong leadership to end child labor by 2025  Context: 2025 targeted as deadline to end child labor 160 million children (almost one in ten) are…
no
0
31
During the Global Solutions Forum on child labor on 2-3 November 2021, the world leaders discussed actions that ought to be taken to end child labor by 2025. The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) pointed out that child labor not only harms a…
0
351
“Validity Foundation, PRISM Impresa Sociale s.r.l. (Italy), Bulgarian Centre for-not-for-profit Law (Bulgaria), and Center for Legal Resources (Romania) invite you to join our Webinar Series on Child-Friendly Justice for children deprived of…
0
124
The present report is a summary of views and experiences described by representatives of various occupations who – in their professional capacity – are likely to encounter children – victims of trafficking or children from groups at risk (e.g.…
no
0
50
Children come into contact with the justice system in many different ways. This can be for family matters such as divorce or adoption, in administrative justice for nationality or immigration issues or in criminal justice as victims, witnesses or…
0
37
This is a child-friendly resource for teaching children about the justice system and how a child-friendly one involves their participation. This includes introducing the people they may encounter, such as police officers and lawyers, as well as…
no
0
29
The last two decades have seen significant strides in the fight against child labour. But the COVID-19 pandemic poses very real risks of backtracking. Positive trends may falter, and child labour may worsen,especially in places where it has remained…
0
139
The European Asylum Support Office has published a practical guide on the best interests of the child in asylum procedures. According to the present legislation, all EU member states are obliged to act in the best interest of a child in the actions…
0
6
The Initiative for Child Rights in the Global Compacts has developed a briefing for young people on the recently adopted Global Compacts for Refugees and on Migration. The aim is to enable children and young people to know what the two…