A Report on Opportunities to Apply Alternatives to Post-Trial Detention in Palestine

"This publication was compiled with the aim of facilitating alternatives to detention and reducing the number of children in detention in Palestine.

This Report covers alternatives to deprivation of liberty, from the prosecution stage onwards, as stipulated in the Palestinian Juvenile Protection Law. It does not deal with diversion. While diversion may be considered an “alternative” insofar as it is used instead of full, formal criminal justice processes, it is different from the other measures listed below as it keeps a young person away from the formal criminal justice system altogether, rather than being a sanction imposed within the criminal justice system. Whereas diversion is a key aspect of any criminal justice system, and while its importance is emphasised in the relevant children‟s rights standards, it is a separate issue to the issue of alternatives to detention.

Linguistically, alternative means “to substitute”, or substituting something with another in the sense of changing it. It can fundamentally alter the nature of the initial phase and requires a transformative process.

Alternative to detention (A2D) has some commonalities with restorative justice systems as opposed to punitive/retributive or welfare models. In cases where there is one or several victims or the community is harmed, A2D aims at reforming a child's life in all its different aspects and at repairing and conciliating the child in conflict with the law with himself/herself, the victim and the community.

This Report draws from the Juvenile Protection Law (2016). As such it may be more relevant in areas of the West Bank where practitioners have started implementing the law. It may be useful however in the Gaza Strip where a different legal regime is in force but similar principles apply. The authorities in Gaza have indicated that failing the enactment of a new Juvenile Protection Law, Article 18 of the “Juvenile Offenders Ordinance” (1937) 2 can be applied to put alternatives to detention into practice. Article 18 allows for the child in conflict with the law to be discharged if he or she recognizes the harm he made. The child can also be placed under the supervision of a probation officer as per Art. 18(c) or a relative or other fit person as per Art. 18(d) of the Ordinance.

What are the Goals of this Report?

This Report was devised with the following intents:

1. Remind the target groups of the concepts and principles of juvenile justice related to the use of alternative measures in light of the relevant international conventions and Palestinian Law (Juvenile Protection Law).
2. Highlight the importance of A2D as a restorative approach and practice.
3. Emphasise children‟s rights at every stage of the judicial proceedings, rehabilitation, reintegration and monitoring.
4. Provide guidance on different phases of children‟s case management benefitting from A2D.

In addition, the Report will provide answers to the following questions:

  • Is the list of alternatives to detention exhaustive or non-exhaustive?
  • Can children above the age of 15 benefit from A2D?
  • Which alternative measures for which offences?
  • Can verdicts regarding alternative measures be appealed?
  • How should the Child Protection Counsellor act if a child violates a judgment imposing an alternative measure?
  • What are the social and legal actions to be taken if the child does not adhere to the conditions of an alternative sentence?
  • What power does the court have to end, modify or replace alternative measures?"
Attachment Size
alternatives_to_detention_report_palestine.pdf1.19 MB 1.19 MB
Publication type
Author
Joseph Aguettant#uid:2026
Khitam Abu Hamad#uid:3231
Mahmoud Abu Kamal#uid:4643
Marta Gil#uid:10722
Total pages
35
Countries this relates to
Language of materials
Projects and thematic pages

Childhub

You might like..

0
40
This report was issued by the People’s Advocate in collaboration with the Observatory for Children’s Rights. UNICEF Albania Office partnered with the Child Rights Observatory to implement the “Strengthening the capacity of the People’s Advocate to…
0
57
In this article, Forbes lists ten common signs one might be experiencing work-related burnout. The American Psychological Association describes job burnout as “an extended period of time where someone experiences exhaustion and a lack of…
0
10
The Entrepreneur writes about the signs of burning out, possible with any kind of job in today's fast-paced working environment. Following new research conducted by the American Psychological Association and the National Opinion Research Center…
0
The current report aims to provide the first ever global synthesis of data on violence based on sexual orientation and gender identity/expression in educational settings, and existing responses by the education sector in all regions of the world,…
yes
0
144
Child-friendly version, explaining to children and young people what it means to keep children safe in sports, what are their rights and obligations and how can they get help.  This publication was made in the framework of the project "Keeping…
0
94
From the preface of the document: Following the initiative of the Hintalovon Child Rights Foundation and its student volunteers, the Child Rights Ambassadors, Hungary's first children's report on the situation of children's rights has been prepared…
0
15
This study was requested by the Committee on Women's Rights and Gender Equality (FEMM ) in November 2018 and is a follow -up to a European implementation assessment carried out by EPRS in 2016 on the Human Trafficking Directive (2011/36/EU). It goes…
0
27
CEOP has carried out a rapid assessment of ‘localised grooming’ in the UK. This is a form of sexual exploitation, previously referred to as ‘on street grooming’ in the media, where children have been groomed and sexually exploited by an offender,…
0
4
Trafficking in human beings in conflict and post-conflict situations is a subject on which little research has been conducted, and which is seldom addressed by the stakeholders tasked with supporting displaced people and/or refugees. In the field,…
0
3
In 2002, the then United Nations Secretary-General appointed Paulo Sérgio Pinheiro as independent expert to provide a global picture of violence against children and to propose recommendations for the prevention of violence. Many member states,…
0
2
The conference addressed the growing interdependence between the formal and informal economy – and those performing formal or informal work – and the challenges that arise from this for trade unions. It particularly focussed on the need to develop…
0
3
The report highlights the cases of 80 children known or suspected of being trafficked into the UK for sexual exploitation, labour exploitation and forced marriage. More shocking is that 48 of these children have gone missing from social services…
0
4
This report is the first large scale exploration, in the UK, of the physical and psychological harms caused and aggravated by the detention of children for immigration purposes. Despite recent statements by the coalition government that the…
0
2
A book for children and young people to help them understand the recommendations of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child. This book will help children: To understand what is necessary for our country to do in order to respect the rights of…
0
121
Today’s children are growing up in a digital age, exposing them to all the wonders and dangers that the internet brings. It’s important to educate children about online safety. It is smart to use on line games to educate children how to be safe…